| Pricing model | Outcome-anchored retainer plus media-spend pass-through. Negotiated rate disclosed, agency margin disclosed. | Flat-fee per placement at list rate. Bundled markup. Margin hidden inside the placement quote. | Salaried lead plus freelance script + edit + report fees. Fixed cost, variable yield. |
|---|
| Fraud screening | 5-signal qualified-view auditor on every KOL before the buy. Hard 25 percent reject floor. | No fraud audit. Roster sold as-is. Engagement-quality data not collected. | Manual sniff test by the in-house lead. No standardized 5-signal score. |
|---|
| Brief mechanic | Every placement briefed from the founder narrative spine. KOL amplifies the owned wedge. | Generic ad copy or KOL-discretion script. Voice does not pair with founder owned channels. | Brief depends on whoever drafted the script that week. Voice consistency drops on travel weeks. |
|---|
| Tracking | Per-post: total views, qualified-view share, cluster-overlap, qualified inbound. Audit ledger every Friday. | Total views and estimated reach (often platform-inflated). No cluster-overlap report. | Spreadsheet ledger with hand-pulled numbers. Friday cadence collapses on busy weeks. |
|---|
| Failure mode | Underperformer cut from rotation. Refund logic per engagement floor. Capital recompounded weekly. | Underperformer stays in rotation. Renewal pitch arrives before the report does. | Underperformer stays in rotation because the in-house lead has a relationship with the KOL. |
|---|
| Cluster fit | Cluster mapped per engagement. Roster does not exist as a fixed list; KOLs picked per ICP. | Roster is the product. Cluster fit is a coincidence, not a design constraint. | Whoever the in-house lead already knows. Coverage outside personal network is thin. |
|---|
| Time-to-first-placement | 14 days from kickoff (cluster + screen) to live placement with founder-approved shortlist. | 7 days (faster) but skipping the cluster + screen layers entirely. | 30 to 60 days while the in-house lead ramps and pulls vendor invoices. |
|---|
| Reporting surface | Weekly Slack ledger: KOL by name, dollars paid, qualified views, cluster-overlap, qualified inbound attributed. | Monthly PDF dashboard: total views, total spend, total reach. Names not attributed to outcomes. | Internal slide deck quarterly. No weekly cadence. |
|---|